Culture First/The 9 Practices/Select the Right People

Select the Right People

“Kissing Frogs Enthusiastically”

The Practice

Selection is the single greatest input you have on your culture. Select the right people means knowing exactly what you're looking for before you start looking (define the prince), knowing what must be hired versus what can be trained (buy vs. build), controlling your evaluation standards (own the yardstick), screening out toxic high performers (avoid the HPA), putting the right people in charge of evaluation (sensei, not Santa or gatekeeper), and understanding that selection never stops.

How It Works

The practice works by converting abstract qualities into observable behaviors, then measuring them rigorously. 'Integrity' becomes 'admits mistakes immediately. ' Character lives in the buy column because no training program installs it; skills live in the build column because they can be developed. Evaluators are chosen for calibrated judgment. And after hiring, daily performance remains the ongoing selection process: you earn this team every day.

Why It Matters

Steve Jobs said his number one job was making sure the top people were A-plus players: 'everything else will take care of itself. ' The inverse is equally true: most organizations hire for résumé and then fire for behavior. The cost of a bad hire will always exceed the cost of a longer search, which is why elite organizations would rather leave a seat empty than fill it with the wrong person. Selection is where you protect culture or lose it. What It Looks Like Done Well In organizations that select well, everyone evaluating candidates works from the same picture of the ideal hire, expressed in behaviors. The hiring bar does not drop when the organization is short-staffed. Peer input carries real weight. Brilliant jerks are declined regardless of the talent shortage. And long-tenured people meet the same standards as new arrivals, because passing selection was never a lifetime pass.

Tools in This Practice

Define the Prince
Every interviewer pictures the ideal candidate differently
Culture First Implementation System, page 65
Buy vs. Build
You keep training for qualities you should have hired for
Culture First Implementation System, page 70
Own the Yardstick
You measure what's easy to score, not what predicts success
Culture First Implementation System, page 74
Avoid the High-Performing Asshole
A star hire is quietly wrecking the team
Culture First Implementation System, page 79
Santa, Gatekeeper, or Sensei
One evaluator rejects everyone; another waves everyone through
Culture First Implementation System, page 84
Earn This Every Day
Long-tenured people coast on reputation
Culture First Implementation System, page 88

Get the Book

Read the full treatment of all nine practices in Culture First.

See the Book

Get the Workbook

Exercises and assessments for installing this practice in your team.

See the Workbook

Take the Assessment

Score your team on this practice with the online CFIS assessment.

Start the CFIS