Culture First/The 9 Practices/Collaborate Deliberately

Collaborate Deliberately

“Thank You for Disagreeing”

The Practice

Thank you for disagreeing. Collaborate deliberately means systematically harvesting the collective intelligence of your organization: tapping hidden expertise (the wisdom of the crowd), verifying reality through direct observation (get to ground truth), suspending hierarchy in planning (rank-off planning), assigning people to attack your plans before reality does (murder your own ideas), and socializing decisions before announcing them (everybody hates surprises).

How It Works

The practice works through structure, not sentiment. You expand the circle on significant decisions instead of relying on the same trusted few. You go and see for yourself, because information filters and distorts as it climbs the hierarchy. In planning sessions, rank comes off and junior people speak first, so senior views don't anchor the room. Red teams of neutral, objective people who were not part of the planning hunt for its weaknesses, and their findings get fixed, not defended against. Decisions reach affected people through conversation before they arrive by announcement.

Why It Matters

A warehouse employee six months into the job caught AAARDVARK misspelled on a catalog cover that a team of experienced professionals had reviewed multiple times. The knowledge your organization needs is distributed across it, often in unexpected places. The smartest person in the room is never one person; it is the room itself. You do not need smarter people. You need more perspectives, and a culture where the truth carries more rank than the person telling it. What It Looks Like Done Well In organizations that collaborate deliberately, fresh eyes catch significant errors because leaders deliberately apply them. Bad news travels upward as fast as good news, intact. The senior person's idea loses regularly enough to prove the system works. Plans survive contact with reality because they first survived contact with critics. And no one who matters learns about a decision from a mass email.

Tools in This Practice

The Wisdom of the Crowd
The same few people shape every decision
Culture First Implementation System, page 147
Get to Ground Truth
Your reports look rosy but the floor tells another story
Culture First Implementation System, page 152
Rank-Off Planning
Your idea always wins in your own planning meetings
Culture First Implementation System, page 157
Murder Your Own Ideas
Plans keep falling apart on contact with reality
Culture First Implementation System, page 161
Everybody Hates Surprises
People keep getting blindsided by decisions
Culture First Implementation System, page 165

Get the Book

Read the full treatment of all nine practices in Culture First.

See the Book

Get the Workbook

Exercises and assessments for installing this practice in your team.

See the Workbook

Take the Assessment

Score your team on this practice with the online CFIS assessment.

Start the CFIS